Five Pizzerias Not to Miss In Tuscaloosa

Written by: Colin Dowling

Whether you’re stepping out of a concert downtown, wrapping up a campus tour, or gathering friends for a low-key night, pizza is always the right call. Think about it?  Who doesn’t love, or at least LIKE, pizza?  While most other cuisines can be debated, very rarely does someone say, “You know…pizza sounds like a bad idea.”

Which is all the more reason why we are thankful that Tuscaloosa has more than a few spots that go beyond the usual slice. These are places where crusts come crisp, cheese pulls matter, and the menu is full of flavor surprises.

In this post, we’re spotlighting five local pizzerias that each bring something unique to the table. From classic pepperoni to house-made sauces and specialty pies, there’s a place here for every taste, mood, and group. These aren’t chain spots. Each of these pizzerias is rooted in the city and worth a visit.

Bring your appetite. You’re going to want more than one slice!

Heat Pizza Bar

Heat Pizza Bar sits right in the heart of downtown Tuscaloosa and has built a following for its artisan-style pies with bold flavor combinations. Think thin, crisp crusts topped with fresh ingredients like Thai chicken, spicy pepperoni, and smoked bacon. Every pizza is made to order, and the menu keeps things interesting with seasonal items and rotating specials.

Inside, the vibe is modern and social. The bar draws a strong happy hour crowd, especially before and after events at the Bama Theatre or the Mercedes-Benz Amphitheater. With plenty of seating and a central location, it’s a go-to for dinner, drinks, and a shared pie. There’s even a parking deck just steps away, making it easy to get in and out.

Locals call it one of the best values downtown. For artisan pizza and a downtown experience, Heat delivers.

TuscNY

TuscNY is a local gem for fans of true New York–style pizza. The crust is thin, the slices are big, and the flavor is all there. This isn’t a fast-casual spot. It’s a place for people who really care about every part of the pizza, from crust to sauce to toppings.

It’s slightly more upscale than the others on this list, which makes it a great option for a more intentional pizza night. Think date night, small group outings, or takeout when you want to treat yourself. The attention to detail sets it apart, from the quality of the ingredients to the way each pie is built and baked.

Locals talk about TuscNY like it’s the best-kept secret in town. The prices run a little higher, but the quality is consistent. For fans of NY-style pizza, this is the spot.

Depalma’s Italian Cafe

Depalma’s isn’t strictly a pizzeria, but their pizza belongs in the conversation. This Italian café in downtown Tuscaloosa has been a local favorite for years. It’s cozy and welcoming, with exposed brick, white tablecloths, and an open kitchen where you can watch the action.

The pizza menu includes both classic and creative options. Guests also come for the calzones, pastas, and signature dishes like baked ziti and seafood ravioli. It’s a first-come, first-served restaurant with no reservations, which makes it feel casual despite the elevated flavors.

Some folks think of Depalma’s as one of the top restaurants in town. Whether you order pizza or something else, the food is consistently excellent. If you’re looking for pizza that comes with a full Italian experience, start here.

Lost Pizza Co.

Lost Pizza Co. is newer to the Tuscaloosa area, but it’s already made a name for itself in Northport. Technically located in Northport, the space feels fresh and welcoming, with a design that mixes industrial finishes and bold graphics. It’s a casual spot where everything is made from scratch, from the dough and sauce to the dressings and sandwich spreads.

The pizza here leans hearty and colorful. Expect a long list of topping combos, along with wings, pastas, and shareable starters. There’s room for families, friend groups, and quick lunches alike, and the atmosphere is laid-back without cutting corners on flavor.

Lost Pizza Co. is a spot where the food looks as good as it tastes, and the menu has something for everyone…even the pickiest eater in your group.

The Standard

The Standard combines two local favorites: pizza and sports. Just a few blocks from campus on University Boulevard, it’s a comfortable neighborhood bar that happens to serve some of the best pizza in town. You’ll find all the classics—pepperoni, cheese, sausage—but also rotating specials and signature garlic knots that fans rave about.

Inside, TVs line the walls, music is always playing, and there’s a full bar that keeps the drinks flowing. It’s easy to grab a seat with friends, catch a game, and enjoy a hot, fresh slice or two. Service gets high marks for being friendly and fast, even during busy nights.

Whether you’re a student, local, or in town for the weekend, The Standard hits that perfect mix of casual and consistent.

Hungry yet?

Tuscaloosa’s pizza scene covers more than just the basics. These five spots offer variety, creativity, and a sense of place, each one with its own take on what makes a great pie. You can go bold with artisan toppings at Heat, keep things fresh and fast at Lost Pizza Co., meet up for game night at The Standard, grab a slice of New York at TuscNY, or pair your pizza with pasta at Depalma’s. Truly something for everyone.

Every option brings something different. Even better, every one is worth a stop. Whether you’re a first-time visitor or a longtime local, Tuscaloosa has the pizza you’re looking for.

A special thanks to our partners at Buffalo Rock for sponsoring this content!